Fr. John O’Connell

Centenary of a Parish founded by a Ballingarry priest

The Story

The Providence Journal of February 1 2. 1910 commented as follows; “Father O’Connell became pastor of St. John’s in Attleboro in November 1882. It was a new parish. There was no church. no house. nothing except the field for work and the people among whom to work.” Before our Parish was ever established, Catholicism had endured a long, difficult struggle in America. It was not until the Revolutionary War that any degree of tolerance was shown to Catholics. There was little organization to the church, vocations were few, and the Catholic population was very scattered. However, a milestone in American Catholic history occurred on August 15, 1790, when John Carroll of Baltimore was named and consecrated the first Catholic Bishop of the United States. This was just a little over a year after George Washington had become the first President of the United States. August 15, the Feast of the Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary, was a fitting day for the occasion, since the country was to be placed under her patronage. New Dioceses were created in Boston. New York, Philadelphia and Bardstown. Kentucky. The Boston Diocese comprised the New

England States and Bishop Jean Cheverus was named the first Bishop by Pope Pius VII on April 8.1808, although he was not consecrated until October. 1810, by Bishop Carroll in Baltimore.

Because of the much longer distance entailed in traveling to this location. the people in East Attleboro decided it was time for them to have a Church of their own, and they sought permission for this from the Bishop of Providence. The railroad had been built in Attleboro in the I830’s and a few of the Irish who had come to work on it had settled here. Consequently. a few more Catholics were now living in the East section.

When Bishop Hendricken gave his consent that a Church could be established in Attleboro. money had to be raised. The parishioners themselves sacrificed tremendously from their meager earnings to contribute to the building fund. One parishioner was even reported to have mortgaged his home to contribute the money to the church fund. and it took him many years to pay off the mortgage. Many money raising events were also held to augment the fund. such as fairs and picnics. Many of these events were held in a field where the Triboro Plaza is now located. In November 1882.

Reverend John O’Connell was given the assignment of being the first Pastor of St. John the Evangelist Church plus the mission church of St. Mary’s in Norton. On the Feast of the Epiphany. January 6, 1883. he began his duties as Pastor. For almost a year he continued to hold services in the Union Hall.

While striving to accumulate sufficent funds to build a church. Union Hall, which was located on Railroad Avenue (the present site of Atherton’s Furniture Store) was the center for social activities at this time. Mr. Lawrence Gilbert of Atherton’s notes that the chandeliers of the old Union Hall are still hanging. now concealed by the store’s second floor ceiling. There was always an event. such as a dance or show, taking place in the hall on Saturday night. Early Sunday morning the parishioners would have to go to the hall. clean it, and get it ready for Mass which would be celebrated by Father O’Connell. who journeyed by train each Sunday from Providence to Attleboro. The first altar used was a large packing box donated by one of the local merchants. The priests’ vestments and the altar clothes were stored under the stage. One Saturday night there was a fire in Union Hall and the owner of the Dean Block offered the congregation the use of Dean Hall. This hall was located on Park Street and also served as the District Court Room. Mass was celebrated here until Union Hall was repaired and services then resumed there until December. 1983. A parcel of land on North Main Street was purchased on March 9. 1883 through the Trustees of the Catholic Society of East Attleboro; William Bowen. William O’Connor, and Matthew Fitzpatrick. Most Reverend Thomas F. Hendricken paid $1,000 for this land. It was purchased from George N. Bliss. trustee of the estate of the late Jerusha Bliss. This land was located where the North Main Street parking lot is now. Directly across from the Rectory. There was plenty of land available in the center of the village, but the reason that influenced the North Main Street purchase was that it seemed to be the most central location for the Catholics then residing in the area. A number of families lived in the Farmer’s section (now the West Street-North Avenue area). where there was a large hoop-skirt mill. Others lived in the area surrounding the present downtown. Few lived on the East side at that time because it was swampy and woody. Consequently. the North Main Street land was favored. The cornerstone of St. John the Evangelist Church was laid September 17, 1883. At this time. Leo XIII was Pope in Rome; Chester Arthur was President of the United States; Benjamin F. Butler was Governor of Massachusetts; the Selectmen in

Attleboro were Job B. Savery. S.P. Lathrop. and B. Porter. Ir. Construction was begun immediately on the basement and when this was completed in December. it was used as the meeting place for services. Twenty pews were installed. and this was sufficient to accommodate the number of parishioners for Sunday Masses at this time. Some of the family names rccorded as being active workers in the building drive for the Church were the Dennis and Bowen families, the Gilroys. the Simms. as well as the McCambridge. Daveys and Perry families.

The first marriage performed by Father O’Connell in the new church was between James Irvin Briggs and Catherine O’Connor on January 4. 1883. The witnesses were John Costelloe and Margaret O’Connor.

The first Baptism recorded in St. John’s was Delia Lemarche, daughter of Francis Lemarche and Grietta Gaboury on March 25. 1883. The sponsors were Henry Gaboury and Delia Laroux.

The funds grew slowly but steadily and. aided by the earnestness and hard work of the Pastor and the parishioners, the building fund was finally completed. A Sketch of the History of Attleboro reported the following about the new church and its Pastor;

“The dedication took place September 22, 1885. the Most Reverend Bishop Hendricken conducting the service. which was very imposing and impressive. Father O’Connell has accomplished much since he entered upon the work of this parish, and he has not only endeared himself to his own people. but has gained the respect of the community by his courteous and friendly bearing towards those with whom he has in various ways. both public and private, come in contact”.

 The new ediface was a wooden structure built in Gothic style. It had a high spire with a cross on the top. beautiful stained glass windows and seated about seven hundred people. There were about 600 parish members. The cost of the church is not known, but according to records. there was a $3,000 mortgage at six percent interest on the building at this time and a sketch of the History of Attleboro says the property was valued at $25,000. The organ in the new church was chosen by Miss Christina M. Scott. a graduate of the New England Conservatory of Music in Boston. She had furnished the music for the Masses in Union Hall and became the first organist in the Church. She also founded and directed a choir. She later became Mrs. Christina Foley. the mother of Stephen H. Foley. who was mayor of Attleboro when the second church was dedicated in 1932, and was the grandmother of Mary Foley Peters. Mary Peters recalls her father telling about his mother and him accompanying Father O’Connell to say Mass in the Mission Church of Norton (before St. Mary’s was built). which was located at the corner of Taunton Avene and Barrows Street. He served as an altar boy and his mother provided the music for the services. These visits were usually made in a horse drawn vehicle. sometimes a sleigh. depending on the weather.

Father O’Connell. fondly known as “Father John” by his parishioners. was a much a loved County Tipperary native having been educated at St. Patrick College. Thurles. On November 1st. I869, he entered Maynooth College to pursue theological studies. He was ordained to the priesthood June l. 1874. Shortly after he was invited by Bishop Hendricken to join the Catholic priests in New England and he accepted his first assignment as assistant at St. Mary’s Church in Fall River in August of that year. After six years there. he was assigned to Immaculate Conception Church in Providence for two years. At this time, Bishop Hendricken chose him to become the first Pastor of the newly created St. John the Evangelist Parish in Attleboro. plus the Norton Mission. When Father O’Connell came to St. John’s. he was doubtless pleasantly surprised to find as one of his parishioners, Mrs. lohn Ryan Dennis. With whom he had grown up in the town of Ballingarry in Ireland. Margaret Dennis recalls frequent visits by Father O’Connell to her grandparents’ home on Hope Street. The house. the yard, the children. and adults all had to be immaculate when t’was known the Pastor was coming to visit!

On sick calls, he either walked or was driven via a horse and buggy by William Bowen of Hope Street. if he were free from his work. Very little information is available about the Rectory and the bit that is, has diverse reports. However, A Sketch of the History of Attleboro says: ‘A lot opposite the Church was purchased by P.M. Carpenter and a commodious and pretty rectory was built upon it. which was finished during I891. The cost was some $6,000.”

During the first years of the parish, Father O’Connell and the parishioners worked diligently to pay off the mortgage. The biggest social event of the parish at that time was the annual Emmet Ball, and this created much excitement. There was always a grand march led by one of the couples in the parish. In addition. the Altar Society in the early 1900’s sponsored a play annually. These were held in the Bates Opera House and were very popular. plus successful. Smaller events supplemented the

fund raising activities to diminish the debt. The parish grew steadily in numbers. As well as stronger in faith. Father O’Connell is remembered by Margaret Gaynor as always remaining close to his parishioners and caring for their needs. She too recalls him making frequent visits to her home to visit her widowed mother and two children.

During his twenty-eight years of service at St. John’s. Father O’Connell was a member of the Board of Examiners for Clergy in the Fall River Diocese, Chaplain of St. John’s Knights of Columbus and the local division of the Ancient Order of Hibernians.

On February 11. 1910, Father O’Connell passed away very suddenly in the Rectory as the result of a heart attack. He was found dying by a priest from the Mission Church in Roxbury. who had been conducting a Lenten service at the church. Dr. Frederick V. Murphy, a parishioner, and Dr. CS. Holden attended him, but the end came in the evening, and was a shock to all. Shortly after his death. Bishop Daniel F. Feehan sent the Vicar General. James E. Cassidy (later to become Bishop Cassidy) to take charge of the parish and make funeral arrangements. The Attleboro Sun of Saturday. February 12. 1910 wrote in Rev. John O’Connell’s obituary: During the many years of his service in Attleboro as the leader of St. lohn’s Church he was a wide dispenser of charity in a quiet and non-ostentatious way. He was always interested in Attleboro and ready at all times to assist and further local enterprise with encouragement and advice. He was an excellent speaker and his sermons have always been an inspiration to his parishioners. He had an honored reputation as a scholar. Wednesday evening. after a particularly arduous day in which he distributed ashes to over 1,200. he preached an unusually eloquent sermon. His final effort will be remembered. The Providence Journal of February 12th 1910 commented as follows;

“Father O’Connell became pastor of St. lohn’s in Attleboro in November 1882. It was a new parish. There was no church. no house. nothing except the field for work and the people among whom to work. At the end of his pastorate. terminated so suddenly by death. the parish has one of the most beautiful churches and one of the handsomest rectories in this vicinity, together with a strong and faithful parish.”

The Funeral Mass was celebrated by the Most Reverend Daniel Feehan. Two hundred priests attended and the church was filled to capacity. Proof of the esteem which Father O’Connell held in the city was that on the morning of his funeral, stores and offices were closed in the center. most factories closed during the hour of the funeral. schools closed early prior to the funeral. and the National flag was at halfmast.

At his own request. Father O’Connell was buried in St. John’s Cemetery. which he had just recently acquired for the parish, and at his grave near the entrance to the cemetery is a monument with a Celtic Cross and inscribed.

“Sacred to the memory of Rev John O’Connell, first pastor of St John’s Parish, Attleboro, born in Ballingarry, Thurles, County Tipperary, 1st September, 1849. Ordained at Maynooth 1st June, 1874. Died 11th February, 1910. Requiescat in Pace. Amen.”



155 North Main Street Attleboro,

Mass. 02703

August 20, 1988

Mr. John O’Connell


Ballingarry, Thurles

Co. Tipperary


Dear John,

I received your letter some days ago. It was good hearing from you, and knowing that your are the grand nephew of Father O’Connell who established this parish. It was really a coincidence that the information about our 100th Anniversary of the parish here reached the papers in Ballingarry.

On the occasion of the 100th Anniversary we had a booklet publish that will give you all the information about this parish and your uncle’s tenure here. It will also give you a photo of the Church that Father John built. Sadly, that Church was burnt down in the 1930’s and a new Church was built to replace the wooden structure that your uncle built. From all accounts your uncle was a fine man and priest, loved and respected by all. I believe that the rectory that we priests live in now was built by your uncle, I am sure that you will find the booklet very interesting.

You mentioned that you wanted a photo of the cemetery where your Uncle John is buried. I got a camera and took two shots of the stone on your uncle’s grave. The photo will also give you some idea of the cemetery that he established. I hope that all this information will tell you something of your uncle John and I am sure that the many pages in the booklet devoted to him and his priesthood at St.

John’s will enlighten you about how good and great a man he was.

I am happy to send you this information. Thank you for your letter and I ask your prayers for myself and the good people of St. John.

I forgot something, The booklet speaks of a Margaret Dennis whose grandparents came from Ballingarry and who frequently had Father John over to their house. Margaret is still alive with a keen mind and I let her niece know about your letter and I told her that you might be getting in touch. Her address is: Miss Margaret Dennis; 94 Hope Street; Attleboro, Mass. 02703  U.S.A.

Take care, John, and the best of every blessing. God bless!

I am,

Sincerely Yours,

Rev. Msgr. John J. Smith